Blog / Hiring
Hiring
1099 contractor vs. W-2 employee: which should you hire?
Almost everyone asks this question the wrong way around. It gets asked as "which is cheaper?" — and the honest answer is that the cheaper option is often the one you're not allowed to use.
Because here's the part that surprises people: you don't get to pick. The IRS treats worker classification as a fact about the relationship, not a choice you make when you set up the payment. You can write "independent contractor" at the top of an agreement, have it signed, pay by invoice, and still have an employee in the eyes of the law.
So this article does two things. First, the money — what each one actually costs, with the 2026 numbers and the arithmetic shown. Second, the rule that decides which one is even on the table for you. Take them in that order and the decision usually makes itself.
What a W-2 employee actually costs
Salary is the number you negotiate. It is not the number you pay. On top of every dollar of wages sit four employer costs, and only the first is widely known.
1. FICA — 7.65%. You match your employee's Social Security and Medicare. Social Security is 6.2% from the employer and 6.2% from the employee; Medicare is 1.45% from each. Your side totals 7.65% of wages. Social Security stops at the annual wage base — $184,500 for 2026 — while Medicare has no ceiling at all.
One asymmetry worth knowing: employees pay an Additional Medicare Tax of 0.9% on wages above $200,000, and you must withhold it — but you do not match it. It's the one payroll tax that's the employee's alone.
2. FUTA — federal unemployment. The rate is 6.0%, but it applies only to the first $7,000 of each employee's wages, and if you pay your state unemployment tax in full and on time you get a credit of up to 5.4%. That brings the effective rate to 0.6%. In dollars: $42 per employee per year, and that's the whole of it.
3. State unemployment (SUTA). This one genuinely varies — by state, by industry, and by your own layoff history. A new employer in a low-risk office role might see something near 2.7% on a wage base in the $15,000 range; other states and industries land well outside that. There is no national figure to quote you, so check your own state's rate rather than trusting any article, this one included.
4. Workers' compensation. Also state-set and class-rated. Clerical work is among the cheapest — a few tenths of a percent of payroll. Roofing is not.
The arithmetic on a $60,000 hire
Putting those together for an office employee at $60,000, using our calculator's assumptions for the two state-set items:
| Cost | How it's figured | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | Agreed | $60,000 |
| Social Security + Medicare | 7.65% of $60,000 | $4,590 |
| FUTA | 0.6% of the first $7,000 | $42 |
| State unemployment | 2.7% of the first $15,000 (assumed) | $405 |
| Workers' compensation | 0.35% at clerical rates (assumed) | $210 |
| Payroll cost before benefits | $65,247 |
So the mandatory add-on is about 8.75% — meaningful, but smaller than the "employees cost 30% more" figure that gets repeated online. That larger number isn't wrong; it's just mostly not taxes. It's health insurance, retirement matching, paid time off, equipment, software seats, and payroll processing. Those are real, and they're the ones you control.
Paid time off deserves its own mention, because it hides in plain sight. Two weeks of vacation plus eight holidays is 18 days an employee is paid and not working — so that $65,247 buys roughly 1,936 hours of work, not 2,080. That's $33.70 per hour actually worked, against a headline rate of $28.85.
What a 1099 contractor actually costs
This side is refreshingly short: you pay the invoice. No employer FICA match, no FUTA, no state unemployment, no workers' compensation, usually no benefits, no paid time off, and no payroll service.
Which makes contractors look dramatically cheaper — until you notice why their rates are higher.
A contractor pays self-employment tax of 15.3% on their net earnings: 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare. That's both halves — yours and theirs — carried by one person. It applies to 92.35% of net earnings, kicks in once net earnings reach $400, and they can deduct half of it when figuring adjusted gross income. The Social Security portion stops at that same $184,500 ceiling; the Medicare portion never does.
They also buy their own health insurance, fund their own retirement, absorb their own unpaid sick days, and pay their own quarterly estimated taxes because nobody is withholding for them. A competent contractor prices all of that in. If their rate looks like a bargain against an employee doing the same job, that usually tells you something about the contractor, not about the structure.
There's a real strategic difference too, and it cuts both ways. A contractor is a variable cost — you buy work in the amount you need, and you stop when the project ends. An employee is a fixed cost you carry through slow months. For lumpy or specialized work, that flexibility is worth paying for. For steady core work, it's just a more expensive way to buy the same hours.
The rule that actually decides it
Now the part that overrides everything above.
The IRS determines classification under common-law rules, weighing evidence in three categories:
- Behavioral control. Does your business control, or have the right to control, what the worker does and how they do it? Set hours, required methods, your training, your supervision — all point toward employee.
- Financial control. Do you control the business side of the job — how they're paid, whether expenses are reimbursed, who provides tools and equipment? A worker with their own tools, their own costs, and the chance to make a profit or take a loss looks like a contractor.
- Type of relationship. Is there a written contract? Do you provide employee-type benefits like insurance, a pension, or vacation pay? Is the relationship open-ended? Is the work a key aspect of your regular business?
The IRS is unusually direct about how to apply these: there is no "magic" or set number of factors that settles it, factors that matter in one situation may not matter in another, and you must look at the entire relationship and consider the extent of your right to direct and control the worker.
Read that last category again, because it's where most well-meaning small businesses go wrong. A bakery paying a bookkeeper by invoice for four hours a month is on solid ground. A bakery paying its only full-time baker by invoice — set schedule, bakery's equipment, bakery's recipes, indefinitely — is not, no matter what the agreement says.
What getting it wrong costs
If you classify an employee as a contractor with no reasonable basis for doing so, you can be held liable for employment taxes for that worker under Internal Revenue Code section 3509. In practice the bill is back employment taxes plus interest — and the hours you spend reconstructing the relationship to defend it.
There is relief, and it's worth knowing before you need it. Under the relief provisions (commonly called Section 530), you may escape the reclassification if you had a reasonable basis for treating the worker as a contractor, you filed all required federal information returns consistently with that treatment — that is, you actually sent the 1099s — and you haven't treated similar workers as employees.
Note what the middle condition rewards: filing the forms. Businesses that quietly skip 1099s to keep things simple are giving up the very protection they'd want if the classification were ever questioned.
The paperwork for each — and the new $2,000 threshold
What you owe the government differs more than the cost does.
| 1099 contractor | W-2 employee | |
|---|---|---|
| Collect up front | Form W-9 | Form W-4, Form I-9 |
| Withhold from pay | Nothing, normally | Income tax, Social Security, Medicare |
| You pay on top | Nothing | 7.65% FICA, FUTA, SUTA, workers' comp |
| Year-end form | Form 1099-NEC | Form W-2 |
| Due | January 31 | January 31 |
| During the year | Nothing routine | Payroll filings; Form 940 by January 31 |
One date note for this filing season. The deadline is January 31 — but January 31, 2027 falls on a Sunday. The IRS instructions for 2026 W-2s accordingly print February 1, 2027, and the standard weekend-and-holiday rule shifts other January 31 deadlines the same way. Worth knowing on the 31st; not worth planning around.
And now the change that matters this year. For tax years beginning after 2025, the minimum reporting threshold for these information returns increased to $2,000, up from the $600 figure that stood for decades. It may be adjusted for inflation beginning in calendar year 2027.
In plain terms: for what you paid out in 2026, you generally file a 1099-NEC for a contractor you paid $2,000 or more, not $600. For a business that uses a handful of occasional freelancers, that can mean the January stack shrinks by half.
Two habits that make January painless either way. Get the W-9 before you pay the first invoice, not in January — chasing a taxpayer ID from someone who no longer needs your business is a genuinely miserable job, and missing one can force you into backup withholding. And keep contractor payments in their own account in your books, so the list of who crossed $2,000 is something you can read off a report rather than reconstruct. That's the sort of thing a monthly close makes automatic.
So which should you hire?
Run it in this order and you'll rarely get it wrong.
- Start with the work, not the cost. Is it ongoing and central to your business, done on your schedule, with your tools, under your direction? That's an employee, and the rest of the question is moot.
- If it's genuinely project-based or specialized — a designer for a rebrand, a developer for one build, a bookkeeper for a few hours a month — a contractor is both legitimate and usually the better deal.
- Compare hourly, all-in, not salary against invoice. The employee number is salary plus about 8.75% in payroll taxes, plus benefits, divided by hours actually worked. Ours came to $33.70 an hour on a $60,000 salary before a dollar of benefits.
- Price the flexibility honestly. If the work will vanish in four months, a contractor at a higher rate can still be cheaper than an employee you have to let go.
- If you're on the line, document why — the tools, the schedule control, the other clients — and file the 1099s. That contemporaneous record is what a reasonable basis looks like later.
One more, since it's a version of this question owners often ask: if the role you're weighing is bookkeeping itself, there's a third option that isn't on this page — outsourcing it to a firm for a flat monthly fee, with no classification question at all. We wrote up the comparison in how much an in-house bookkeeper costs in 2026.
The short version
A contractor costs you the invoice; an employee costs salary plus roughly 8.75% in payroll taxes — 7.65% FICA, $42 of FUTA, and state unemployment and workers' comp on top — before benefits and paid time off, which are usually the bigger number. But cost doesn't decide it. The working relationship does, under a three-part IRS test that no contract can override. And for 2026, the 1099 filing threshold is $2,000, not $600 — which changes who gets a form, and nothing else.
This is general information, not tax advice for your situation. Figures here are federal rules for the 2026 tax year; state unemployment and workers' compensation rates are set by your state and insurer, and the ones used above are our calculator's assumptions, clearly marked. Check anything time-sensitive against the IRS pages linked below before you act on it.
Where these numbers come from
Every federal figure above is from the IRS directly, not from a summary of it:
- The 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare rates, the $184,500 Social Security wage base for 2026, and the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax over $200,000 — Topic no. 751, Social Security and Medicare withholding rates, irs.gov
- The 6.0% FUTA rate, the $7,000 wage base, the 5.4% state credit, the resulting 0.6% effective rate, and the Form 940 due date — Topic no. 759, Form 940, Employer's Annual Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return, irs.gov
- The 15.3% self-employment tax rate and its 12.4%/2.9% split, the 92.35% of net earnings, the $400 threshold, and the deduction for half of it — Topic no. 554, Self-employment tax, irs.gov
- The common-law rules and the three categories of evidence, the "no magic formula" language, Form SS-8 and its timescale, section 3509 liability, and the Section 530 relief provisions — Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?, irs.gov
- The increase of the reporting threshold to $2,000 for tax years beginning after 2025, inflation adjustment from calendar year 2027, and the January 31 filing deadline for Form 1099-NEC — Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC, irs.gov
- The February 1, 2027 date for filing and furnishing 2026 Forms W-2 — Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3, irs.gov
The state unemployment rate (2.7% on the first $15,000) and workers' compensation rate (0.35%) used in the $60,000 example are the default assumptions in our own hiring cost calculator, shown as illustrations rather than published national rates — yours will differ.