Skip to content

Before you hire in-house

Hiring your own bookkeeper?
See what an employee really costs.

An in-house bookkeeper's salary is the small part. Payroll taxes, benefits, recruiting, turnover and your own management time all land on the same line item, and none of it shows up in the offer letter.

True cost of an in-house hireUpdates as you type

The role you'd post

$35k$95k

Employer share of single coverage, roughly $7,900/yr.

Adjust assumptions

Federal payroll tax at published rates, plus assumed state unemployment and workers' comp: 7.65% FICA (6.2% Social Security + 1.45% Medicare) on wages, $42 FUTA after the standard state credit, 2.7% state unemployment on the first $15,000, and 0.35% workers' compensation at clerical rates. State unemployment rates vary widely — yours may differ.

What an employee actually costs, per year

Wages paid$55,000
Employer payroll tax$4,847
Benefits$7,900
Software & tools$2,400
Recruiting, amortized$1,600
Your management time$4,800
Employee all-in, per year$76,547
That's 1.39× the salary you'd post $1,615 per working week
In-house, per month
$6,379
plus turnover risk and coverage gaps
UT Advisory, per month
From $250
a month for bookkeeping only; fuller plans with payroll and tax are quoted on a free 15-minute call
Want the other number?
A flat monthly fee, quoted before any work starts.
Book a free 15-minute call

A salaried hire is unavailable about 23 days a year once PTO and holidays are counted — the close still has to happen those weeks.

Illustrative, not a quote. Figures use published federal payroll tax rates and typical small-employer averages for benefits and insurance; your actual costs vary by state, carrier, and plan. UT Advisory's fee isn't modelled here: it is one flat monthly number, quoted on the call or by email within a day, from the package you choose, your transactions, the accounts we reconcile and the size of the business. Payroll and catch-up, if you need them, are priced on their own.

What an in-house hire actually costs

A salary line on a job post hides five other bills.

Payroll tax, benefits, tooling, the recruiting you'll repeat when they leave, and the management time that never makes it into the offer letter. Stack them up and the picture changes.

What one hire has to know, and what a team covers

One bookkeeper. Five different jobs.

Your books need more than data entry. Closing the month, payroll and its filings, catch-up work, keeping the books ready for tax time, and the tax return each take their own know-how, and the rules change every year. One hire has to be good at all of it, or you pay later to fix what they missed.

  • ✓
    Month-end closeReconciling, categorizing and closing the month the same way every time.
  • ✓
    Payroll and its filingsPay runs, payroll tax filings, W-2s and 1099s, tracked to their deadlines.
  • ✓
    Books kept with the tax return in mindWhen we prepare your return*, it's built from the books we keep.
  • ✓
    Catch-up and clean-upMonths behind is work we take on regularly, not a one-off your hire figures out.
  • ✓
    Rule changes are our jobKeeping up with tax and payroll changes is part of the work, not something learned on your time.
  • ✓
    No single point of failureMore than one person knows your books, so vacations, sick days and turnover are covered.

What you get instead

The whole job, done — without the headcount.

One engagement covers the monthly close and the tax return it feeds*. A dedicated team and one dedicated contact, who learn how your business actually earns.

  • ✓
    Books reconciled every monthYour accounts tie out to the bank — not once a year in a panic.
  • ✓
    Statements you can readA monthly P&L, balance sheet, and cash view, in plain terms.
  • ✓
    Tax prep and filing, handled*The books feed the return. No March fire drill.
  • ✓
    A dedicated team and contactOne contact who knows your business, with a team behind them, so the close never rests on one person.
  • ✓
    Catch-up on the months you're behindWe clean up the backlog first, so you start from a clean ledger.

Straight answers

Before you post that job.

Where do these numbers come from?
Payroll tax is calculated from published federal rates — 6.2% Social Security and 1.45% Medicare on the employer side, plus FUTA after the standard state credit and an assumed 2.7% state unemployment rate on the first $15,000. Benefits, workers' compensation, and software use typical small-employer figures, all of which you can change under "Adjust assumptions." Nothing here is a quote.
Why include my own time as a cost?
Because it's the cost owners most consistently forget. Someone has to answer the bookkeeper's questions, review the close, approve payroll, and manage them. Four hours a month is a conservative estimate, and at most owners' hourly value it exceeds the software line by a wide margin.
What if I hire part-time instead?
Set the schedule to 20 or 30 hours and the gap narrows — that's a fair comparison and the calculator shows it honestly. If you wouldn't offer benefits, set that to "None" and watch the largest add-on disappear: the federal coverage mandate only applies to employers with 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees, so below that size it's your call either way, and part-time roles are commonly wages-only. What part-time doesn't solve is coverage: one person still means one point of failure at close.
Our books are months behind. Is that a problem?
No — it's the normal starting point. Catch-up of the months you're behind is scoped on the call as a one-time piece, separate from the monthly fee.
Do we keep our accounting software?
Yes. We work inside your accounting software, so you keep your history and never migrate or learn a new tool.

Skip the hire

Book a free 15-minute call.
Get a real number.

Tell us what you were about to hire for and where the books stand. We'll usually tell you what it costs on the call, or by email within a day, and what month one looks like.

Book a free 15-minute call Re-run the math

Or send us a message through our contact form

Book a free 15-minute call