Blog / Deals
Deals
Buying a small business: the financial due diligence checklist
The listing says the business earns a certain amount a year. The seller is friendly, the broker is optimistic, and the letter of intent is signed. Now you have a few weeks to find out whether the numbers are real.
That window is financial due diligence. It is where a buyer learns what they are actually paying for, what problems come with it, and how the deal's structure will affect their taxes for years. It is also the part of a purchase that is easiest to rush.
Where diligence fits in the deal
Most small business purchases run in roughly this order. The SBA's guide to buying a business lists the same documents.
- Confidentiality agreement, so the seller can share real numbers.
- Letter of intent: price, structure and main terms in outline.
- Due diligence: financial, legal and operational. The financial part is this article.
- Purchase agreement, drafted by the attorneys, including any purchase price adjustment.
- Closing, then the transition: new tax accounts, payroll and bank accounts in your name.
What you find in step 3 can change the price, the structure or the terms in step 4. That is the whole point of doing it before you sign.
1. Do the returns, the books and the bank agree?
Ask for three years of federal tax returns, the profit and loss statements and balance sheets for the same years, and the bank statements. Then compare them:
- Revenue on the returns vs. revenue in the books. They should match, or the difference should have a clear reason, like cash vs. accrual timing.
- Revenue in the books vs. deposits in the bank. Add up a year of deposits, take out transfers between accounts, loans and owner contributions, and compare. A business that "earns more than it reports" is telling you its returns are wrong. That is a problem for the buyer, not a selling point.
- Year-to-date numbers for the current year, compared with the same months last year.
- Sales tax returns vs. reported sales, for businesses that collect it.
2. Earnings and add-backs
Small businesses are usually marketed on an earnings figure that starts with profit and adds back the owner's salary, the owner's perks, interest, depreciation and one-time costs. Each add-back raises the earnings, and the asking price with them.
Test each one:
- Is it documented? A personal vehicle or family phone plan run through the business should show up in the ledger and the receipts.
- Is it really one-time? A lawsuit settlement may be. A "one-time" repair that happens every year is not.
- Will you need to replace it? If the owner works 60 hours a week, adding back their whole salary assumes you will work those hours for free. If you plan to hire a manager, their pay comes back out.
- Are there costs missing? Rent below market from a related landlord, family members working unpaid, or equipment that is past due for replacement.
3. Customer concentration
Ask for revenue by customer for each year. If one customer is a large share of sales, the business is partly a bet on that relationship continuing after the owner leaves. Check whether there is a contract, how long it runs, whether it can be assigned to a new owner, and whether the relationship belongs to the business or to the seller personally.
4. Receivables and payables
Get the accounts receivable aging and the accounts payable aging as of a recent month-end.
- Receivables: how much is past 60 or 90 days, and is any of it really collectible? Old balances that inflate the balance sheet also inflate any working capital figure built from it.
- Payables: are vendors being paid on time, or has the seller been stretching bills to make cash look better before the sale?
- Customer deposits and prepayments: if customers paid for work not yet done, someone has to do that work after closing. Find out who.
5. Payroll and sales tax liabilities
Unpaid taxes are a common surprise after closing. Ask for the payroll tax returns (federal Form 941s, Utah withholding returns, unemployment reports) and the sales tax returns, and check that what was filed was also paid.
Utah has a specific rule for buyers. The Utah State Tax Commission tells purchasers to get a Letter of Good Standing from the seller showing all taxes are filed and paid, or a letter stating no sales or special fuel taxes are due. If taxes are unpaid, the buyer should withhold that amount from the purchase price and pay it to the Tax Commission within 30 days of the final sale. A buyer who skips this can be held liable for sales and special fuel taxes the business already owed. Utah tax licenses are not transferable, so the buyer applies for new ones. If the business keeps the same federal EIN, the new owners notify the Tax Commission of the new owner and officer information on form TC-69C.
Other taxes and liabilities have their own rules, and in a stock purchase the company's history comes with it. How far your exposure goes, and how the purchase agreement protects you, is a question for your attorney.
6. Asset purchase or stock purchase
This is the decision with the longest tax tail, and the buyer and seller usually want different things.
- Stock purchase: you buy the owner's shares and the company continues. For the seller, the IRS says selling stock usually produces a capital gain or loss. For you, the company, its contracts, its tax accounts and its past come along.
- Asset purchase: you buy the business's assets, often through a new company of your own. The IRS treats a lump-sum sale of a business as a sale of each asset separately, which sets your tax basis in each one. That basis drives what you can depreciate or amortize.
Form 8594: how the price gets allocated
In an asset purchase, buyer and seller must both allocate the price using the IRS's residual method, across seven classes in this order:
| Class | What goes in it |
|---|---|
| I | Cash and bank deposit accounts (not CDs) |
| II | CDs, government securities, foreign currency, actively traded property |
| III | Accounts receivable and other debt instruments |
| IV | Inventory |
| V | Everything else: furniture, fixtures, vehicles, equipment, buildings, land |
| VI | Section 197 intangibles other than goodwill, such as a covenant not to compete |
| VII | Goodwill and going concern value |
Each class (except VII) gets no more than its fair market value, and whatever is left over lands in goodwill. Why it matters:
- For you, equipment in Class V is generally depreciated on its own schedule, while goodwill, going concern value and a covenant not to compete are amortized over 15 years (180 months).
- For the seller, the IRS says inventory produces ordinary income, while depreciable or real business property held more than a year falls under section 1231. So the seller has their own reasons to push the split one way.
- It is binding. If buyer and seller agree on the allocation in writing, that agreement binds both of them unless the IRS finds the amounts aren't appropriate.
- Both sides file it. Buyer and seller each attach Form 8594 to their income tax return for the year of the sale, and file a new one for any later year the price goes up or down, as with an earnout.
Because both returns report the same split, the allocation is worth modeling before it goes into the purchase agreement, not after.
7. Working capital
Many deals include a working capital target: the receivables, inventory and prepaid items, less payables, that the business needs to run. If the business arrives with less than the target, the price is adjusted. Without a target, a seller can collect receivables and leave the bills, and you start day one needing cash. Agree on what counts, how it is measured and when it is checked after closing.
Who does what
A small business purchase usually involves three kinds of professionals, and the SBA suggests a buyer hire an attorney and an accountant.
- The broker runs the process: introductions, the timeline and the back-and-forth between the parties.
- The attorney drafts and negotiates the letter of intent and purchase agreement, reviews contracts and leases, handles licenses and permits, and protects you against liabilities you didn't agree to take on.
- The accountant or financial advisor reviews the numbers and earnings, ties returns to books and bank, tests the add-backs, and models the deal with its tax impact, including the Form 8594 allocation and working capital.
What commonly goes wrong
- Accepting the seller's earnings figure without seeing the bank deposits behind it.
- Add-backs that assume the buyer works for free.
- Skipping the tax letters, then finding a sales tax balance after closing.
- Leaving the price allocation to the last week, so the two sides' Forms 8594 don't match.
- No working capital target, and an empty bank account on the first payroll.
- Books kept on a different basis from the returns, so nothing ties and the diligence clock runs out.
The short version
Before you sign, make the returns, books and bank deposits agree for three years. Test every add-back. Know your largest customers, the age of the receivables and what is owed. Confirm payroll and sales taxes are paid, and in Utah get the Tax Commission's letter or hold back the tax from the price. Understand whether you are buying assets or stock, and model the Form 8594 allocation and the working capital target before they are written into the agreement. Then plan the first month after closing, when the books, payroll and tax accounts move to you. If you are on the other side of the table, read what buyers look for in your books, and our services page covers getting a business's books ready before buyers look.
This is general information, not tax or legal advice for your situation. Deal structure, liabilities and contracts are for your attorney; check anything time-sensitive against the IRS, SBA and Utah pages linked below.
Where these rules come from
- Documents in a purchase (confidentiality agreement, letter of intent, contracts and leases, financial statements, tax returns, sales agreement, purchase price adjustment) and hiring an attorney and an accountant: Buy an existing business or franchise, sba.gov
- A business sale as a sale of each asset, the residual method, the seven classes, the fair market value cap, binding written allocations and both parties filing Form 8594: Publication 544 (2025), Sales and Other Dispositions of Assets, irs.gov
- Filing Form 8594 with the return for the year of sale, covenants not to compete in Class VI, and a new Form 8594 for later price changes: Instructions for Form 8594, irs.gov
- Stock sales usually producing capital gain, inventory producing ordinary income and section 1231 treatment of business property held over a year: Sale of a business, irs.gov
- The 15-year (180-month) amortization of goodwill, going concern value and covenants not to compete: Instructions for Form 4562 (2025), irs.gov
- The Letter of Good Standing, withholding unpaid tax from the price, the 30-day rule, successor liability for sales and special fuel taxes, new licenses and form TC-69C: Purchasing or Selling a Business, Utah State Tax Commission